The federal False Claims Act (FCA) and its state counterpart, the Florida False Claims Act (FFCA), empower private citizens to file lawsuits against employers or companies that are defrauding the government. When you see a company knowingly overbilling Medicare or a contractor cutting corners on a federal project, these laws provide a path to hold them accountable.
In one recent fiscal year alone, the Department of Justice recovered over $2.9 billion from companies that committed fraud against the government. More than $2.4 billion of that amount came directly from lawsuits initiated by whistleblowers, who were awarded over $400 million for their courage.
Yet, the decision to report fraud is never easy. You may fear for your job and your reputation. Recent legal challenges, like the September 2024 ruling in U.S. ex rel. Zafirov v. Florida Medical Associates right here in Florida, have created confusion about the stability of these cases.
Despite this, the Middle District of Florida remains one of the busiest jurisdictions in the nation for these exact types of lawsuits. A path exists to expose wrongdoing, recover stolen taxpayer funds, and potentially receive a significant financial reward—all while securing legal protection against employer retaliation.
If you have witnessed fraud and are concerned about your rights, we are here to help. Call Brenton Legal today for a confidential consultation.
Key Takeaways for Florida False Claims Act Lawsuits
- The False Claims Act offers substantial rewards for reporting fraud. As a whistleblower, you are entitled to 15–30% of the total funds recovered, which includes three times the amount of the fraud plus steep per-claim penalties.
- Federal and state laws provide strong anti-retaliation protections. You are legally shielded from being fired, demoted, or harassed for investigating or reporting fraud, with remedies that include double back pay and job reinstatement.
- The First-to-File rule makes acting quickly essential. Only the first person to file a lawsuit about a specific fraud scheme is eligible for a reward, which makes it important to consult an attorney promptly in a high-volume jurisdiction like Florida.
The Mechanics of Justice: How the False Claims Act Works
The idea behind these laws is centuries old, rooted in a concept known as qui tam, which is short for a Latin phrase meaning “he who sues on behalf of the King as well as for himself.” In the modern context, you—the whistleblower, legally referred to as the Relator—sue on behalf of the U.S. government.
The Two Key Statutes
Most fraud cases involving government funds in Florida trigger two primary laws:
- The Federal False Claims Act (31 U.S.C. §§ 3729–3733): This is the bedrock of whistleblower law and applies whenever federal money is stolen. Think of fraud involving Medicare, military contracts (TRICARE), or pandemic relief loans.
- The Florida False Claims Act (Fla. Stat. §§ 68.081–68.092): This law mirrors its federal counterpart but is designed to recover funds defrauded from the State of Florida, such as the state’s share of Medicaid payments. A fraudulent act frequently violates both federal and state laws simultaneously.
What Does It Mean to Act Knowingly?
You do not have to find a smoking gun email where an executive explicitly states an intent to defraud the government. The legal standard, as defined in 31 U.S.C. § 3729(b)(1), is broader. A company is liable if it acts with:
- Actual knowledge: The company knew the claim was false.
- Deliberate ignorance: The company intentionally buried its head in the sand to avoid learning the truth.
- Reckless disregard: The company failed to take reasonable steps to ensure its claims were accurate.
The government simply cannot police every single invoice and contract. It relies on insiders with integrity to expose fraud that would otherwise go undetected. This is why these laws were created: to empower and reward those who speak up.
The Financial Incentives: Damages, Penalties, and Relator Shares
For defendants, the monetary consequences are severe. For the whistleblower, the potential reward is substantial, recognizing the personal and professional risks involved.
Treble Damages
First, the government is entitled to recover three times the amount of money it lost due to the fraud. This is known as treble damages. If a healthcare provider defrauded Medicare of $5 million, the government could recover $15 million.
Civil Penalties Per Claim
On top of treble damages, the law imposes a hefty penalty for each false claim submitted. These penalties are adjusted annually for inflation, but they typically fall in the $10,000-25,000 range. Imagine a medical lab that submitted 1,000 false claims for unnecessary tests. The penalties alone could reach millions of dollars, sometimes dwarfing the actual amount of the fraud itself.
The Relator’s Reward
As the whistleblower, you are entitled to a percentage of the total recovery. The exact amount depends on whether the government decides to intervene, or take over the primary prosecution of the case:
- When the Government Intervenes: You are typically eligible for 15% to 25% of the recovered funds.
- When the Government Does Not Intervene: If the government declines to take the case, you and your attorneys have the option to pursue it on your own. If you are successful, your share increases to 25% to 30% of the recovery.
The Florida False Claims Act, under Fla. Stat. § 68.085, offers similar percentages for the portion of the funds recovered for the state.
Why Florida Is Ground Zero for False Claims Act Litigation
Florida’s massive economy, large senior population, and significant number of federal contractors make it a natural hotspot for government fraud. In fact, research shows that the Middle District of Florida, which includes Tampa, Orlando, and Jacksonville, has historically been the busiest federal district in the entire country for these cases.
Concentrated Fraud Risks
Several factors contribute to Florida’s high volume of qui tam lawsuits:
- Healthcare Hub: With millions of residents reliant on Medicare, the opportunities for fraud are immense. We frequently see schemes involving Medicare Advantage risk adjustment, billing for non-existent hospice care, and illegal kickbacks for patient referrals.
- Pandemic-Related Fraud: The rush of federal funds from programs like the Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) led to widespread abuse. The DOJ has made prosecuting PPP loan fraud a top priority.
Cybersecurity Fraud: As a growing hub for the defense and tech industries, Florida has many government contractors. The DOJ’s Civil Cyber-Fraud Initiative is actively targeting companies that falsely certify they meet federal cybersecurity standards, putting sensitive data at risk.
The Zafirov Constitutional Challenge in the Middle District of Florida
In September 2024, a federal judge in the Middle District of Florida ruled in U.S. ex rel. Zafirov v. Florida Medical Associates that the qui tam provision of the False Claims Act is unconstitutional. The ruling argued that allowing a private citizen to sue on behalf of the government violates the Appointments Clause of the U.S. Constitution.
This decision has certainly introduced a new layer of difficulty, but it does not mean your case is over before it begins. The ruling is only binding in that specific case for now and is expected to be appealed to the Eleventh Circuit. It does, however, underscore the importance of having knowledgeable legal counsel who understands how to handle these evolving challenges, whether through appeals or by pursuing parallel strategies in state court.
Identifying Fraud: Common Schemes We See in Florida
Fraud takes many forms, from complicated billing schemes to blatant falsehoods. If you work in healthcare, defense, or any industry receiving government funds, you may recognize some of these common patterns.
- Phantom Billing: This is one of the most straightforward types of fraud. A provider bills the government for services, medical equipment, or prescriptions that were never actually provided to the patient. This is particularly common in home healthcare and telemedicine.
- Upcoding: Here, a provider performs a simple, lower-cost service but submits a bill to Medicare or Medicaid using the code for a more complex and expensive service.
- Illegal Kickbacks: The Anti-Kickback Statute (AKS) makes it illegal to offer or receive anything of value to induce referrals of patients covered by federal healthcare programs. If a pharmaceutical company pays a doctor consulting fees that are actually just a reward for prescribing its drug, any resulting claims to Medicare are considered false.
- Medicare Advantage Risk Adjustment Fraud: Health insurers in the Medicare Advantage (Part C) program receive higher payments for sicker patients. Some companies illegally inflate their profits by submitting falsified patient diagnoses to make their enrollees appear less healthy than they truly are.
- Cybersecurity Non-Compliance: A government contractor may win a bid by certifying that it meets specific, rigorous cybersecurity standards. If the company knows it does not meet those standards, any invoices it submits to the government under that contract could be considered false claims.
Employment Protection: What If I Am Retaliated Against?
The single greatest fear for most whistleblowers is losing their job or their career. The architects of the False Claims Act understood this. That is why they built powerful anti-retaliation protections directly into the law, a shield our firm is deeply experienced in enforcing.
Your Rights Under Federal and Florida Law
Both federal and state laws make it illegal for your employer to punish you for reporting fraud:
- Federal Protection (31 U.S.C. § 3730(h)): The FCA protects employees, contractors, and agents from being “discharged, demoted, suspended, threatened, harassed, or in any other manner discriminated against” for taking lawful acts in furtherance of an FCA case.
- Florida Protection (Fla. Stat. § 68.089): The Florida False Claims Act contains its own provision that offers similar protections at the state level.
You do not have to file a lawsuit to be protected. The law shields you for actions like investigating the fraud, raising concerns internally to a supervisor, or even refusing to participate in the illegal activity yourself. As long as your employer has reason to believe you are trying to stop fraud, any punitive action against you could be considered illegal retaliation.
Remedies for Illegal Retaliation
If your employer violates these protections, you are entitled to significant relief. A successful retaliation claim provides for:
- Reinstatement to your position with the same seniority.
- Two times the amount of back pay (lost wages), plus interest.
- Compensation for any special damages, including emotional distress and the costs of litigation.
And what if you signed a Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA)? Generally, an NDA cannot be used to prevent you from reporting illegal activities to the government. The law ensures that private contracts do not muzzle whistleblowers or conceal fraud against taxpayers.
FAQ for Florida Whistleblowers
What is the statute of limitations for filing a False Claims Act suit in Florida?
The deadline is governed by a complicated rule. Generally, a lawsuit must be filed within 6 years of the violation. However, the law allows the suit to be filed up to 3 years after the government knew or should have known about the violation, but in no event more than 10 years after the fraud occurred.
Can I report fraud if I was involved in it?
Yes. The law is designed to encourage people to come forward, even if they participated in the wrongdoing. Your share of the recovery might be reduced, but full cooperation is looked upon favorably. However, if you are criminally convicted for your role in the fraud, you will be barred from receiving any award.
Does the government intervene in every case?
No. Both the federal and state governments intervene in a minority of cases, typically fewer than 25%. If they decline to intervene, it does not mean your case has no merit. It simply means they have chosen not to dedicate their resources to it. As mentioned, you and your legal team have the right to proceed with the lawsuit on your own.
Are whistleblower awards taxable?
Yes. The IRS generally treats qui tam awards as taxable income. How it is taxed is complicated, and some portions, such as attorney’s fees, may be treated differently depending on the circumstances. Always consult with a financial professional after a successful recovery.
What happens if the public already knows about the fraud?
This relates to the Public Disclosure Bar. The law may prevent you from bringing a case if the fraud has already been revealed in channels like the news media or a government report. The main exception is if you are an original source of the information, meaning you have independent knowledge that “materially adds” to what is already public.
Silence Is Not a Strategy: Protect Your Career and The Public Trust
Waiting is rarely the best course of action for a whistleblower. The First-to-File rule means every day of hesitation is a risk that someone else will report the fraud first, barring you from your right to a reward. Meanwhile, the absolute deadlines set by the statute of limitations are unforgiving.
Fraud against the government is not a victimless crime. It steals money from programs meant for our seniors, our soldiers, and our infrastructure. You have a legal right to help stop it and a statutory right to be compensated for the risk involved.
If you have evidence of fraud, we will help you evaluate your claim and understand your employment protections. Call Brenton Legal today to discuss your situation in complete confidence.
Ryan Brenton
Ryan Brenton, the founding partner of Brenton Legal PA, is a distinguished employment lawyer with a profound experience in a variety of employment disputes. His practice encompasses complex litigation, wage and hour class action cases, and discrimination, harassment, and retaliation claims. Representing a diverse clientele, from minimum wage workers to executives, Ryan has successfully argued cases in both state and federal courts, as well as in administrative proceedings. His legal acumen has earned him a national reputation and respect from clients and peers alike. A graduate of Nova Southeastern University, Shepard Broad Law Center, and holding a B.S. in Economics from Florida Atlantic University, Ryan's legal prowess is underpinned by a solid educational foundation. His commitment to justice and fairness in the workplace marks him as a trusted advocate in the field of employment law.
Read More Articles By Ryan Brenton